Best device for Coreelec in 2025 (and 2026)

It’s not really “closed” source. The firmware is available and also the drivers in source.
They are just not compatible with mainline. It’s too specific, hardware focused.
So it will stay forever to give only full support by vendor kernel.
The hardware was and will not mainline, it will ever be a vendor tree.
And Torvalds will never accept such “big” vendor specific changes.

But I heard in background it is worked on 6.12 vendor kernel already…

2 Likes

Some hints point towards Rockchip (a chipset still in development) rather than Amlogic for the upcoming Khadas VIM5. To be confirmed…

1 Like

Rockchip doesn’t change the fundamental issues with all ARM hardware.

That’s disappointing if the VIM line goes Rockchip, there’s already the Khadas Edge SBC line for Rockchip. Amlogic SOC development has been too slow the last 5-8 years, Rockchip blew by them, so maybe not a complete surprise. Rockchip announced 2 new chips last summer, the RK3668 and RK3688. Maybe it’s based on one of those.

Just in terms of raw CPU power the S905X5 is ~40K DMIPS. The RK3668 is 200K DMIPS, and RK3688 300K DMIPS.

1 Like

It’s not that surprising that AMLogic have slowed development. Their primary market is media players and their current chips are more than adequate for that function. Developing beyond what is needed is just wasted money.

1 Like

Hi, I’m looking for a new device. It has to play DV (not FEL), HDR and support all audio formats as passthrough. As I understand the Homatics Box R 4K Plus should be the best choice to date. However I’ve just found out that there’s a new Homatics Box 4K V2 coming out soon.

Now my doubt is: buy the older device with a better supported SoC or wait for the newer one ? I mean, so much work has been done on fine tuning the S905X4 and I think it has years of future CE releases ahead. I don’t know, maybe buying a device with the S905X5M right now it’s not the right move. I don’t see any advantage and by the way when things like, for example, H266 support will be a relevant thing, at that point my hypothetical S905X4 box will have already played lots of contents :grin:

Is my argument valid or I am overlooking something…

Thanks

1 Like

Ok, so I’ll try with a simpler more direct question maybe I’ll be more lucky :winking_face_with_tongue:

Homatics Bos R 4K Plus or Rocktek G2 ? So USB vs MicroSD… I’d like the idea of having nothing sticking outisde the box, but I don’t know if the micro sd slot is comparable with the USB slot performance wise. Any experience to share about that ?

Same thing from a CE perspective, flip a coin.

Use a low profile usb problem solved 256GB USB 3.1 Flash Drive FIT Plus | Samsung US

Use case dependent, never had any issues with microsd but if you’re seeing slowdowns you can always redirect paths with path substitution. https://kodi.wiki/view/Path_substitution

If it were me and I had issues I would mount the android data folder and redirect the thumbnails cache to the internal emmc.

1 Like

With my 2 x Tox3’s I tried usb and sd in the hidden slot. I found no issues with either and I now just use sd cards (16Gb)

2 Likes

This thread will have a major revision in the next few days as the capacites of new devices becomes clearer.

2 Likes

Yep, did just that in Kodi forum for overall best boxes thread. Nice to have new FEL options when it seemed unlikely last year.

I just want to know that is this a good price to buy ugoos am 9 pro for fel

And do this support cmv2.9 or cmv4.0 with latest dovi and corelec no update

As it is my first ugoos device and confused to buy am9 pro and am6b plus

I was also looking for future proof

I would suggest buying the AM6b+. It still is the best player. It supports LLDV with both cmv2.9 and cmv4.0 as well as TV-led Dolby Vision.

If you have a DV TV with TV-LED support, then for now the AM6B+ is more stable and better. I’m currently testing ce22 and comparing it with am6b+, so far there are a lot of bugs and glitches when working with DV. We need to wait until all the major sores are resolved. Therefore, if here and now, am6b+ is better. If for the future, then the am9 pro

And what “lot of bugs”? I know only one, ok two when I include the FEL seek not stable as bug.

4 Likes

Dv in tv-led send as 10bit rgb.

Some DV files output as HDR. Some dv files with black screen in lldv mode.

from what I’ve noticed so far, I’ve been making quick comparisons.

On my TV TV-led mode works normally, 8-bit RGB DV for all DV videos.

Your default GUI settings: Resolution, refresh rate?
log: dmesg|paste

Also please link on samples, bug description, steps to repeat for each issue you found could help to solve it.

P.S.: This issue FEL - Amlogic NO support - #156 by sat4all with conversion to DV will be solved in next nightly.

Yep, same here. All Play fine with RGB 8bit in DV-Std mode. And 422, 12 bit in LLDV mode.

The VS12 convert is fixed with tomorrow nightly.

No log, no problem…

1 Like

Okay, I’ll double check on the latest nightly version. I tested it on the version dated May 7.

1 Like